PFM SolutionsPFM Solutions

Research & perspective

Financing equitable immunization in Pakistan

A published study opens an important financing question: how should programmes balance wider coverage with reaching underserved communities?

PFM Solutions — AI-assisted editorial content
· 3 min read

The research

The 2022 BMJ Global Health paper, Cost optimisation analysis of the expanded programme for immunisation: balancing equity and coverage in Pakistan, examines the relationship between immunization coverage and equity. Its costing exercise covered 16 geographically and demographically diverse districts in Pakistan. The study considers different combinations of delivery approaches for reaching children under five.

Hammad Yunus is a co-author, with PFM Solutions listed as his affiliation. His role in leading the unit-cost component is described in the firm’s related case study. This contribution forms part of a wider research collaboration; it should not be read as leadership of the entire study.

The central question is whether pursuing the highest average coverage also serves underserved populations. Readers should consult the original paper for its methods, assumptions and findings. The practical questions below are editorial reflections, rather than additional findings or claims of implemented results.

Source: Houdroge et al. (2022), BMJ Global Health 7:e009000 — publication record and original-paper links ↗

Begin with the decision

Before commissioning a costing exercise, a programme team should write down the decision it needs to make. Is it choosing where to expand services, how to organise outreach, or how to distribute a fixed budget? Each question calls for a different comparison. A useful brief would identify the population, the service package, the planning period and the alternatives that decision-makers can realistically adopt.

We would also ask the team to specify its equity objective. That could mean prioritising communities with low coverage or setting a minimum service expectation across areas. These are proposed planning choices, not targets prescribed by the paper. Making the choice visible allows finance and programme teams to discuss the same objective before reviewing a model’s recommendations.

Make cost comparisons meaningful

A practical review should ask what each estimate includes. Does it cover staff time, transport, supervision and shared support? Does it describe cash required for the next budget, or the wider value of resources used? We recommend showing these boundaries alongside the estimate so that a reader can judge whether two figures are comparable.

The denominator deserves the same attention. A planning table should state exactly what is being counted and over what period. Rather than presenting one apparently precise unit cost, the team could show the assumptions that matter most and discuss how the recommendation changes when those assumptions change. This would make uncertainty part of the decision rather than a footnote.

Turn analysis into a feasible financing option

For each proposed delivery option, we would prepare a short implementation note: which institution is responsible, what inputs are required, when funds must be available and how progress will be checked. The discussion should include the managers who would carry out the work. Their task would be to identify practical constraints and explain which assumptions need revision before an option enters a budget proposal.

Any contemporary application should use updated prices, service information and local operating assumptions. The publication date should remain prominent; a historical study is not a current budget quotation. A new proposal should also distinguish the additional cash needed from resources already available, and make any continuing obligations visible to the institution expected to finance them.

Keep the evidence open to scrutiny

A useful decision record would set out the chosen option, the alternatives considered, the equity objective and the evidence still missing. It should identify when the decision will be revisited and who will review it. This is the practical value we seek from cost evidence: a clear basis for discussing choices, with enough transparency for others to challenge the assumptions and improve the plan.

Sources & further reading

Sources checked 2 October 2026. Practical recommendations are editorial proposals; they are not claims of project outcomes.